Has American Idol jumped the shark?











5 comments:

Jason Fullen said...

Confession: I watched the other night with Rachel because she had it on, and ... I liked it. I know, I am shallow. I think it feeds the side of me that loves to hear Simon create every possible way known to man to insult someones gift or lack thereof. Funny thing is they can't even control it.

Jumped the Shark? I don't think so - because eventually there will be 3 and those 3 will have fans and people will watch.

Susie Moore said...

Maybe it hasnt jumped the shark yet but it is definitely on the skis and headed towards the ramp... I always enjoy watching it in the beginning but towards the end I get disinterested.

Todd Wright said...

I'm not normally one to side with Rosie O'Donnell, but it does seem the show's taken an even more cruel turn this season. I don't watch the show, but I've been pretty turned-off by the clips I've seen.

I'm all for Simon telling people the truth...but I just don't like watching people get humiliated.

Susie Moore said...

lol not one to usually side with Rosie O'Donnell...

Robert Conn said...

I never really thought it had jumped the shark... I just heard that on the radio last week and wanted to know everyone's opinion.

Subscribe